Just Maintaining: Are Maintenance Fees Climbing on NYC Co-Ops Another Reason Buyers Favor NYC Condos?

Posted on Tue, 09-14-2010

Months ago, when we noted the recent spike in , the comparison came alongside much attempted soothsaying and no small amount of confusion. The absorption rate on NYC condos and NYC co-ops converge around the $1 million mark, but the way in which upscale Manhattan condos were outpacing similarly priced Manhattan co-ops was striking enough to note even then. That trend shows no sign of diminishing with news that co-op maintenance fees jumped $1.76 per square foot -- an increase of 19% -- over the past year. The condo renaissance -- an ambiguous, tenuous, neighborhood-by-neighborhood renaissance, but one all the same -- continues apace, it seems, in part by default. But what's going on with those NYC co-ops?19%, for real? How did Manhattan apartment-seekers get turned off to co-ops in the first place? The Journal's Brittany Hutson explained it fairly well back in June. "Foreign luxury buyers, a big part of Manhattan's luxury market, continue to buy and tend to favor condos because they're easier to acquire," Hutson wrote. "But high-paid executives in the finance industry, traditionally a big part of the market for luxury co-ops, aren't spending as much and are buying less. Those who remain in the market are having trouble meeting the stricter guidelines of the notoriously picky co-op boards." That jumping-through-hoops aspect of buying a NYC co-op apartment probably has something to do with their relative decline in popularity, but a 19% spike in fees is... well, it's pretty good, as reasons go. So, why did these hikes happen? "The main driver behind the fee increases has been a jump in property taxes brought on by rising state and local debt," Smart Money's AnnaMaria Andriotis writes. "Property tax revenue from New York City co-ops increased 9.68% to $12.8 million in 2009, the most recent data available, according to the NYC Department of Finance. Co-op boards looking to offset rising property taxes have few options but to raise maintenance fees, which shareholders (the people who purchase each unit) pay on a monthly basis separate from their mortgage." There are various advantages to investing in a Manhattan co-op or condo, of course, but this story offers a rich depiction of two reasons why many people searching for Manhattan apartments opt for condos -- in-your-business co-op boards to rising fees. Take it all together, and it wouldn't be surprising to see the gap between co-ops and condos -- which has favored co-ops dramatically for generations -- continue to narrow.

Legal Stuff

The owner of this website is not a licensed real estate broker or representative of the buildings or apartments contained on the website. This website is strictly for informational purposes. There are no property listings on this website. Nothing contained on this website shall suggest the availability of a property or guarantee the accuracy of accompanying prices.

If you would like more information about a property, we will connect you with a real estate broker who will be able to give you more information about available apartments and schedule a showing.